How to Re-Engage Lapsed Members Without Discounting
In an industry obsessed with chasing new members and new leads, it is important for independent gym owners to look at their ex-membership, why they decided to leave, and most importantly, whether they can be won back.
While it might feel good to engage in a massive outreach campaign in an area your gym has never targeted before, it is vital that we never underestimate the benefit of a warm lead.
Because at the end of the day, cold leads have to be convinced of everything. The facility, the price, whether the gym’s service is worth their time at all. A lapsed member already made the decision to join once, and unless a club really dropped the ball, there is every chance they might again.
Because unlike every other cold lead our theoretical gym is targeting, we know these ex-members once picked this gym over the others and kept showing up. And we also know that life has a habit of getting in the way.
Bringing them back becomes less like closing a sale and more like touching base. Not only that, it is an invaluable tool for gathering feedback. If a former member is so put off by a gym’s service that they will never, ever consider coming back, most gym owners should be very curious and keenly want to know why that is the case.
And if they aren’t that put off, then there might be a chance to get them back on the books.
Now obviously this is highly specific. If an independent gym or fitness club had a rough period, whether it is a bad manager or staff-shortages or significant repairs. There is every chance that many members might not fancy a re-do. But if nothing dramatic has happened, there is every chance that many of those ex-members just had life get in the way.
Don’t Devalue Your Brand
Most independent clubs still default to an offer when a membership lapses: half price for the first month, or a free trial disguised as a welcome-back gesture. It’s an easy card to reach for, and it can produce a short-term bump in reactivations and retention.
But it is a short term solution to what might be a long term problem. Discounting a returning member is a tacit admission that the gym was never had that much faith in the original price, and it slowly teaches the wider membership base to try their luck rather than stick it out.
Suddenly the message to anyone still paying full price seems to be that leaving and coming back beats staying put. It encourages the wrong behaviour and risks turning a gym’s membership roster into a revolving door that will be spinning constantly. This can be especially detrimental when we consider that not everyone leaves because of, or has issue with, membership price, but if they spot a chance for a bargain they’d be a fool not to take it.
The better tactic is relevance. A win-back email addressed to “valued member” and offering 20% off reads as generic and usually gets deleted before the target has read past the subject line. No-one has ever felt like a valued member because someone put it in the first line of an e-mail.
But an e-mail that references the classes someone actually attended, or notes that the amount of time since their last visit. That reads as though a person paid attention to them rather than just a system working through a list. This is where independent gyms and fitness clubs have an advantage. Even if a chain actually put the time to go through these lists, many members would assume it was still a cynical ploy, but people want, hope and expect their local businesses to be paying this sort of attention. And facilities that meet that expectation might find some familiar faces back on their gym floors.
Structure, Storage, Systems
Most independent gyms should already have a lot of this information in their membership management software. Whether it is attendance history, preferred classes, hopefully even the reason given at cancellation if an exit survey was sent and answered.
The information doesn’t need to be exhaustive, just enough that they can tell this was an e-mail written to them and not a generic mail blast.
To this end, tone matters as much as content. A message that opens by asking how someone has been getting on, rather than leading with a discount, can work better depending on a gym’s brand identity.
If a gym fosters their image as a local gym that is invested in their members journey, this sort of e-mail feels much more believable than a gym that has gone for a sleek, detached image. Not to say either of these are wrong, of course. Each appeals to a different type of person, but a gym’s brand identity should, of course, inform how these messages are composed.
Time also gives clubs a legitimate reason to get back in touch that has nothing to do with price. Whether it is a new class being added to the timetable or a new area/feature opening up in the facility, there are many genuine reasons someone might consider rejoining a gym.
An e-mail that says “here’s what’s changed since you left,” and actually knows when the member left is a genuinely piece of engagement. Of course, it does require something to have actually changed in a facility, but even changes to class offerings and equipment can be enough. Not everything has to be big news about a rebrand or refurbishment.
Speaking of time, time should necessarily change the content of these messages. A member who cancelled four weeks ago still remembers the layout of the changing rooms and what classes are running. It would feel strange to send them the same message as someone who quit eight months ago. A short note, nothing more than asking whether everything’s alright, usually does the job.
A member who left a year ago is a different case. Whatever routine replaced their gym attendance is probably a firmly established part of their life by now, and a generic invitation to return is unlikely to make them return.
It is important to remember that Summer disrupts routines for almost everyone, through holidays or a change in childcare. A lapsed member who left in June or July usually fell out of a habit that might have lasted without the disruption.
To that end, messaging built around getting back into an autumn routine taps into something the member is likely already feeling, and is likely to be that much more effective for it The same logic applies again after Christmas, though January is likely to be a more competitive time, given the number of gyms that run January marketing campaigns.
Barriers to Entry
Finally, adding complexity risks killing off a members desire to join before it has finished forming.
Asking a lapsed member to dig out a forgotten password or ring the front desk during office hours is a barrier to entry we don’t need to be putting up.
A rejoin link that already knows their name and member profile details is the beginning of a smooth journey back into your books. It might feel like a small detail, but just like online joining, it is important to underestimate the power of convenience.
Needless to say, once a gym has undertaken this kind of ex-member re-engagement, it is vital to understand the success rate of this re-engagement. Reactivation rate is the most obvious and visible metric for success, but it is worth tracking how long returning members stay the second time round, and how quickly they came back after being contacted. A campaign that brings people back for six weeks before they lapse again is not the sort of return on investment most gyms will be looking for.
As with any campaign, it should be a living process, innovated and adapted based on the successes, failures, and feedback it receives along the way.
Making membership cheaper is the easy and costly way to win members back. But giving them relevant reasons to return, delivered at the right time, with an easy way for them to act on it, can deliver a great deal more value for your business. Relevance, timing and ease do more work than price, and they protect the value of your membership rather than eroding it.
For clubs managing this at scale, keeping track of who has lapsed and when they are likely to respond is difficult to do from memory or a spreadsheet. Ashbourne’s Prospect Management and Marketing Support tools help independent gyms segment lapsed members and time these campaigns without adding to the front desk’s workload.
And here at Ashbourne Membership Management, we have been helping independent gym and fitness club owners protect their revenue and boost their margins for nearly thirty years now.
Whether it is managing and chasing membership payments, installing innovative access controls, or creating, setting up, and maintaining their websites, we have ensured that thousands of gym owners have been able to spend more time growing their business.
If you want to see how a company made by and for independent gym owners could help you deliver even more value to your members without losing any control over how your facility is run, don’t hesitate to book a demo with our in-house, UK based team today.
Fair Rates For Fitness
If you are reading this, it is likely that you are someone who is invested in the wellbeing of the UK’s fitness industry. With so much change at the top level of the UK’s government right now, there is something we’d like to mention, something important to all of us working and operating within the fitness industry.
Here at Ashbourne Membership Management, we have been proud to work in this dynamic, innovative sector for three decades. At time of writing the UK government has decided to increase business rates as part of the latest budget. While we are always happy to pay our way, we believe that these rates do not acknowledge the incredible benefit that independent gyms and fitness clubs bring to society.
Andy Burnham has already proven he is willing to use Business Rate cuts as a tool to stimulate growth for ‘social’ businesses. Well we ask, if the fitness industry isn’t a social and beneficial sector for the UK as a whole, what is?
Every party manifesto claims that they want the people of the UK to be healthier, happier, and more active. But when the time comes to match action to rhetoric, our industry is too often left out.
So, if you want to make your voice heard alongside the hundreds who have already acted, follow the link here to Fair Rates for Fitness, a campaign being championed by our partners over at the Gym Owner’s Forum.




























